For years, in the UK, we've relied upon Germans to make cars for us. They're good at that. The cars are a bit boring/ordinary but they are almost as reliable as Japanese cars. They have been found guilty of naughtiness. Should we buy Japanese now?

8

8 Answers

Rooster Cogburn Profile
Rooster Cogburn , Rooster Cogburn, answered

After what I've read, the people at VW should be ashamed of themselves. Japanese cars are great cars but they've had their problems also but they never tried to hide it or cover it up. Personally after working on cars for so many years, I prefer Japanese cars over German cars although they kept me in business. I don't know if I would just switch over just yet. Give them a little time to see if they make good on what they did. Meanwhile, go rent a Camry for the week-end and you may never go back !

DDX Project Profile
DDX Project answered

I mean sure I'm disappointed at VW and all. But the Golf GTI and R are absolutely terrific cars for the money. In terms of affordability, usability, and fun factor; nothing on the market beats these cars. Audi has always been my brand of choice.

I don't think Japanese cars have much to offer these days in terms of fun factor. I  drove the the Lexus RC F Sport, and thought it was pretty bland. Acuras are ugly in my opinion. If I had no other choice, a Honda Accord Coupe v6 with a manual would be alright for a budget car (They always have the best looking butts). But then I even prefer a Ford over them these days. Those new rendition of the Mustangs are quite the beauty. Along with their budget friendly hatchbacks Focus and Fiesta ST.

Do note, that I am American. Volkswagen doesn't have much of a market share compared to Toyota/Lexus and Honda/Acura. So what's considered as blandmobiles to me might not be for you.

4 People thanked the writer.
Ray Dart
Ray Dart commented
Hmm. I've driven both of those VWs (The Audi is also a VW, And I haven't driven EVERY Audi, I have to admit.) Fast off the mark and quite good fun in that respect, but noisy and in most other respects, a trifle dull. Hey, there are no interesting British cars these days. I should shut up :)
DDX Project
DDX Project commented
Because they all got bought up by other companies. I'm a Mini Cooper fan myself.
Maurice Korvo Profile
Maurice Korvo answered

Why not buy a car built in the UK?

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automotive_industry_in_the_United_King


5 People thanked the writer.
Ray Dart
Ray Dart commented
The ones I can afford are a bit dull (but Japanese so will be reliable). The fun ones, Jags, Astons, Bentleys are a tad more than I am prepared to pay. The UK is now the largest car producer in Europe. We make loads of Toyotas, Hondas, Nissans. We are also the largest engine manufacturer in Europe thanks to Ford, who don't actually make cars here anymore. (If you are still awake, thanks for reading :) )
Maurice Korvo
Maurice Korvo commented
I always wanted a Bentley, but price made it unobtainable, so we got a dog and named him Bentley. Now I can go out each morning with my Bentley (even though we are walking). (I am still awake, as I am in western Canada, and its the middle of the afternoon now :) )
dragonfly forty-six Profile

My German husband who is a master mechanic isn't overly effected by said scandal. While the Germans have made quality beers, sausage, and most things well, when it came to their cars he hates them. My husband would shoot himself in the leg before EVER buying a VW. As someone who works on cars their design is azz backwards he says. Not too excited by the Japanese "rice burners" either. Although, he does like Honda, Accura and Lexus. He'd say buy American.

4 People thanked the writer.
Rooster Cogburn
Rooster Cogburn commented
Being that I worked on cars almost 35 years, German and American cars kept me in business with constant repairs whereas the Jap cars were usually only in the shop for collision repairs. With the exception of Nissan ! Junk !
dragonfly forty-six
I always knew when he had to work on a VW. Heck, everyone knew! He was loud and very vocal about it!
Rooster Cogburn
Rooster Cogburn commented
I had a German car specialist ! He was always busy.
Walt O'Reagun Profile
Walt O'Reagun answered

What do the street racers in the UK use?
In the US ... Their "starter car" is usually a Honda Civic.

As to VW ... I think their solution is going to be the simplest one - "correct" the software so the emissions control is on ALL the time.  Even though it will result in less power/etc - it will allow them to easily, quickly, and cheaply meet US EPA standards.

3 People thanked the writer.
View all 5 Comments
Ray Dart
Ray Dart commented
All Hondas (including the fast Civics) are seen as "old peoples cars" in the UK. Worthy, reliable, well made and DULL. (And I have owned 5 Hondas (3 cars, 2 bikes) so I am actually a Honda fan).
Ray Dart
Ray Dart commented
Volkswagen make good cars with good engines. But they are not THAT special, and they extracted money on flawed advertizing. (And "functionally speaking" they lied to everyone, and then lied twice more to cover up the first "lie".) But, hey, no-ones perfect!
DDX Project
DDX Project commented
I like how everything is the opposite. Here Hondas and most Japanese cars in general tend to be your hand-me-down first car and the first car you buy out of college. Mazda Miata, Honda Civic, Toyota Corolla, etc. Volkswagen is looked upon as pretty exotic, one step below Audi and BMWs. Especially in crowded cities where hatchbacks gaining popularity, the Golf is the leader of the pack since it has a higher end interior compared to plastic Ford Focus and more performance compared to the Civic SI.
otis otiscambell Profile

Being a ex mech for Chrysler dodge I can tell you that they would set the carb so lean to meet EPA regulations but it ran like cr*p. Every carb had to be adj this is the same thing with vw, they will change the computer or software and it will run lean and the customer will see it runs like cr*p.

RIK RZ Profile
RIK RZ answered

Are you talking about the VolksWagon scandal?

K. B.  Baldwin Profile
K. B. Baldwin answered

I miss the real British cars.  Owned a '59 Hillman Estate Sedan, and drive the occasional MG and Triumph back in the day.  A lot of fun to drive with distinctive styling.  They had personality.  My Hondas have all been far (far, far) more reliable than the English cars (and that damned Fiat also), but  when I move on to my next car, I will forget it.  I still remember the English iron.

Answer Question

Anonymous